Near Indiana University, many houses that come up for sale have spent years as rentals.
Indiana's property tax caps distinguish between homesteads and residential properties that aren't homesteads, including rentals.
Two Caps, One House
Indiana limits property taxes as a share of gross assessed value. A homestead's tax bill can't exceed 1 percent of its gross assessed value. Residential property that isn't a homestead, rentals included, falls under the 2 percent circuit breaker. According to the Department of Local Government Finance, a property has to be receiving the homestead deduction to get the 1 percent cap.
Both of the city's taxing districts near campus carry rates high enough for those caps to come into play. According to DLGF's 2026 certified tax rates by district, the certified gross rate is $2.1061 per $100 of assessed value in Bloomington City–Bloomington Township and $2.1032 in Bloomington City–Perry Township. Those are taxes payable in 2026, the bills that came due in May and November of this year.
Here is the math for one house with a $300,000 gross assessed value in the Bloomington City–Bloomington Township district, using the pay-2026 deduction rules. It applies the gross rate before any other credits, so treat it as an illustration of how the caps work, not a quote of anyone's bill.
| Pay-2026 illustration, $300,000 gross AV | Rental | Homestead |
|---|---|---|
| Deductions applied | 6% rental deduction, $18,000 | $48,000 standard, then 40% supplemental, $100,800 |
| Net assessed value | $282,000 | $151,200 |
| Gross rate × net AV | About $5,939 | About $3,184 |
| Cap, as share of gross AV | 2%, or $6,000 | 1%, or $3,000 |
| What sets the bill | Rate math, just under the cap | The cap |
| Further credit | None | Supplemental homestead credit of up to $300 |
On the rental side, the rate math lands just below the 2 percent ceiling. On the homestead side, the rate math runs past the 1 percent ceiling, so the cap sets the bill, and then the new supplemental homestead credit can take off up to another $300. That credit is the lesser of $300 or 10 percent of the tax liability. The house is the same and so is the address. In this illustration, the homestead bill is roughly half the rental bill.
The Gap Moves Every Year Through 2031
Senate Enrolled Act 1 of 2025 rewrote both sides of that table, and it changes them a little more each year. The Monroe County Auditor's homestead page lists the homestead schedule by tax year, and DLGF's deductions and credits presentation sets out the new rental deduction.
| Taxes payable in | Homestead standard deduction | Homestead supplemental deduction | Rental deduction, 2% cap property |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $48,000 | 40% | 6% |
| 2027 | $40,000 | 46% | 12% |
| 2028 | $30,000 | 52% | 19% |
| 2029 | $20,000 | 57% | 25% |
| 2030 | $10,000 | 62% | 30% |
| 2031 and after | $0 | 66.7% | 33.4% |
The supplemental deduction comes off whatever assessed value is left after the standard deduction, and it can't exceed 75 percent of gross assessed value. As the flat standard deduction shrinks, the percentage deduction grows. For a house in the price range of the example above, the homestead's net assessed value keeps falling year after year. The rental deduction grows on its own track at the same time.
The pay-2027 rates haven't been certified yet. But if the 2026 rate held, the $300,000 homestead's rate math in 2027 would come to about $2,957, just under its $3,000 cap, and the rental's would come to about $5,560.
The Herald-Times summed up the first year of these changes as producing "modest bill reductions for many homeowners" in its May 2026 report on who is paying more or less.
Where the Capped Dollars Show Up
When a cap holds a homestead's bill below what the rate would produce, local government absorbs the difference. An estimates worksheet for 2026 projects the City of Bloomington's tax cap and circuit breaker credit loss at $354,600, its supplemental homestead credit loss at $1,210,000, and its total projected property tax credit loss at $1,589,700. Those figures are estimates, not final collections. They show that the caps and credits described above are real line items in the city's budget, and they shape the rates DLGF certifies each year.
This post is general information about how Indiana's property tax rules work, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm your own filing status and deadlines with the Monroe County Auditor or a qualified tax professional.
When you're ready to check your current home's value, start with our instant home valuation.